Creatine?

by SideBurn   October 12, 2011  

Does it work? Or do you pay lots of £ and get expensive urine as a result? Thinking

13 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

The latter....

IMHO

(and I've yet to see any evidence to the contrary, certainly for endurance based sports)

posted by Dr_Death [32 posts]
12th October 2011 - 23:48

0 Likes

I am surprised by the lack of response to this question. Thought this would cause a right old fashioned bun fight! Until recently my opinion was the same as Dr_Death but after a glowing reference from someone I gave it another go. I aim to do 10 to 14hours a week and find I loose a bit of motivation sometimes, creatine seems to give me a bit of a boost of motivation. Is it my imagination?? The product seems to be targeted more at speed and strength (as Dr_Death suggests) but also says it is good for recovery and this is why I will probably keep taking it. Anyone else got an opinion or know of authoritative research? Thinking

posted by SideBurn [804 posts]
31st October 2011 - 13:26

0 Likes

Agree with SideBurn. Would love to hear more - anecdotal evidence or scientific.

Low Speed Wobble's picture

posted by Low Speed Wobble [140 posts]
31st October 2011 - 14:37

0 Likes

Perhaps road.cc forumites are either unaware of the claims or not interested.

I have seen it discussed elsewhere but I'm not into taking expensive supplements so haven't taken much notice. Spend your money on something that you know will work.

Simon E's picture

posted by Simon E [1963 posts]
2nd November 2011 - 10:55

0 Likes

Not used it at all, have body builder mates who are always using it, but to be honest i don't know the benefits

I'd just my money and get some motivational music you'll enjoy while on the bike or something like that

But if you wanted to go down the supplements route, there are many other things that would help far more then creatine in my eyes

Gkam84's picture

posted by Gkam84 [8853 posts]
2nd November 2011 - 16:06

0 Likes

In the States all the Major League Baseball players were using it (along with steroids). At the time, popular thinking suggested Creatine was good for building muscle mass and strength, HOWEVER when it came to endurance in a sport (running/cycling) it was found to cause cramping of muscles.

Good luck and let us know how it works out. I think I will stay with whey protein drinks though.

Tripod16

posted by Tripod16 [110 posts]
2nd November 2011 - 23:13

0 Likes

There is a nice Wikipedia page on creatine supplements. Bottom line seems to be that it may help repeated anaerobic sprint efforts (like a points race on the track), but is no help for sustained aerobic exercise (which is what most cyclists do).

two wheels good; four wheels bad

posted by cat1commuter [1344 posts]
3rd November 2011 - 13:06

0 Likes

Cheers cat1commuter; some interesting stuff!

posted by SideBurn [804 posts]
3rd November 2011 - 15:59

0 Likes

Creatine made a huge amount of difference to me when I was looking to gain lean body mass for rowing in a former life. There's no question about that, but I'm a vegetarian so get very little creatine in my diet. Meat eaters are getting creatine anyway so the benefits are generally going to be lower.

Most studies say that it is beneficial for developing explosive strength/power, but you'll also gain mass. The cons outweigh the pros in endurance sports.

That said, I've just started my own little experiment. I've not used creatine in 10 years but I'm now using it for four weeks just to see what (if anything) happens. I'm interested in resting heart rate, weight, power, recovery, and so on. As it's the off-season, I'm not particularly bothered if I gain a few pounds temporarily in the process.

posted by Mat Brett [1887 posts]
3rd November 2011 - 17:09

0 Likes

he's like a human guinea pig! and all because you asked Smile

what shall we get mat on next? answers below...

Dave Atkinson's picture

posted by Dave Atkinson [7378 posts]
3rd November 2011 - 17:44

0 Likes

"what shall we get mat on next? answers below..."
EPO! I'd love to know the difference it would make to a club level rider.

posted by benezeir [55 posts]
4th November 2011 - 21:47

0 Likes

EPO...the diffrence between life and death from a blood clot?

posted by SideBurn [804 posts]
5th November 2011 - 19:58

0 Likes

benezeir wrote:
"what shall we get mat on next? answers below..."
EPO! I'd love to know the difference it would make to a club level rider.

I might not be up for that one.

posted by Mat Brett [1887 posts]
6th November 2011 - 0:59

0 Likes