Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Light weight comfortable saddle for 200 lbs rider

My original saddle was a 2006 Specialized body geometry Avatar 143 with small gel pads and Chro-mo rails.It weighs a chunky 400 grams but my backside loved it, I clocked many thousands of miles including 400 miles in 4 days without any soreness.

However I am a self confessed "tweaker" and I am always looking to improve my bikes, so ahead of a W2W ride in October this year I swapped out the the 143 for a much lighter Specialized Phenom Expert with Ti rails, to my bum its a WMD !

Any ride over 30 miles causes pain that lasts for days, I have not gone beyond 80 in a day and after about 500 miles on it I have decided its going on ebay.

The big difference between the two saddles is the size of "seating" area, the Phenom Expert has a much larger platform and the larger area protrudes further forward which is where I think my problem arises from.

Can anyone recommend a saddle that weighs sub 300 grams and has a small seating area similar to the 143, see the two images below - many thanks Paul

http://www.specialized.com/OA_MEDIA/equip/05SaddleAvatar143_blk_l.jpg

http://www.cyclesurgery.com/pws/UniqueProductKey.ice?ProductID=CSBC0746W...

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

26 comments

Avatar
Bike Swanky | 9 years ago
0 likes

Selle SMP make some great saddles for all posterior shapes and sizes  3

http://www.sellesmp.com/smp4bike/en

Avatar
yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes

Me a dude - really ? That's funny - if only  21

Avatar
yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes

Dude, I am not a dude. I'm far too old, my youngest child is 21 and my oldest 30 and thankfully they have never called my dude even though they think I'm cool  1

Bottom line is I like light bikes, I also like tweaking them and those two things are complimentary. On these long dark days/nights a little bit of time invested on the web searching for a lighter more comfortable saddle is something I'm ok with plus I have learnt a few things on the way. A Romin Expert 143 should be with me on Wednesday, onward and upward !

Avatar
fenix | 9 years ago
0 likes

Dude - at 200lbs it's pointless to only want a light saddle. Comfort is key.

Try a heavy saddle. You won't be able to feel any difference in the weight of the bike.

Avatar
gazza_d | 9 years ago
0 likes

I'll third the comment about leather saddles. Ridden a Brooks team Pro for 20+ years and it's wonderful.

Recently added a Spa Cycles Nidd to the collection (so I have leather on both main bikes) and it is as comfortable as the Brooks at a third of the price. the Nidd is my daily saddle on a 35 mile return commute.

You need to stick with leather as they may feel uncomfortable on a long ride at first. but unlike anything else they mould to your arse beautifully.

Avatar
Bazza155 | 9 years ago
0 likes

I have a Flite Titanium I bought close to 20years ago and it's great.

Avatar
jhamlin38 | 9 years ago
0 likes

if you want Light, go for fizik aliante VS
if you want comfort.... Uncompromised comfort, for hour upon hour in the saddle, it's a "no brainer"
Brooks B-17 Imperial "Standard" This is the wide B-17 with cutout.
everything else will only "seem" comfortable for a month of 2 hour rides, then you'll notice increasing discomfort, sooner into rides.
Not the case with the brooks.
Furthermore, the brooks is AS COMFORTABLE, if you have "steep" saddle-bar drop, "level" saddle bar drop, or a fairly upright position.
It's the most versatile saddle I've used in over 30 years of cycling. I wish I didn't wait until 44 years of age to "give in" and try it.
Next is a swallow...

Avatar
bike_food | 9 years ago
0 likes

For me Specialized all the way, I used Toupe of some form Expert or pro for a number of years but did manage to snap them both after a year or so of use, I've started using Romin evo pro recently and can't fault it.

Avatar
andyp | 9 years ago
0 likes

ffs, some idiots on this thread.
Ride whatever saddle you want and don't let numpties try to dictate what you can and can't do. FWIW when I was over 200lbs I always used a Selle Italia SLR Kit Carbonio, it's by far the comfiest saddle I've ever tried.

Avatar
yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes

Chris does Strava have a KOA (king of assumptions) feature or Podiums for being patronising ? If so I have no doubt you will leave mere mortals like me in your Strava dust.
I have got enough info from the helpful, non-patronising readers to progress and as I said earlier, life's all short too to get hung up over your point of view, your entitled to it and I wish you well. The last word is all yours if you want it, I'm off to ride my bike no matter how cold it is  103

Avatar
KirinChris | 9 years ago
0 likes

You're worried about 0.1% of your total weight load? FFS  29

Avatar
yespsb replied to KirinChris | 9 years ago
0 likes
abudhabiChris wrote:

You're worried about 0.1% of your total weight load? FFS  29

Where did I say I was worried ?

I think it is you who should be worried  17 You clearly have nothing better to do with your time than to take a perfectly natural request to improve the comfort and weight of my bike and turn in a discussion based on percentages and then use the percentage you have calculated as means to potentially demean me ( btw I've no idea if your calc is right or wrong, time is precious and life's too short to bother with such things)

ps Heres a career tip. Don't apply for a job at British Cycling because it would appear they care about the cumulative benefit of small percentage gains  3

Avatar
KirinChris replied to yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes
yespsb wrote:
abudhabiChris wrote:

You're worried about 0.1% of your total weight load? FFS  29

Where did I say I was worried ?

I think it is you who should be worried  17 You clearly have nothing better to do with your time than to take a perfectly natural request to improve the comfort and weight of my bike and turn in a discussion based on percentages and then use the percentage you have calculated as means to potentially demean me ( btw I've no idea if your calc is right or wrong, time is precious and life's too short to bother with such things)

ps Heres a career tip. Don't apply for a job at British Cycling because it would appear they care about the cumulative benefit of small percentage gains  3

Well thanks, and here's a tip in return, which I don't need to work at British Cycling to know...

If Brad Wiggins turns up weighing 90kg it will be quite some time before the weight of his saddle enters their thought processes.

If you think you're achieving a marginal gain you don't understand the meaning.

You don't start with marginal gains, you finish with them, after you've done the obvious stuff. It's just another version of the 80:20 rule.

Avatar
Felix28 | 9 years ago
0 likes

I am using an old and newer model of the Romin Expert gel which have wings that curve downwards a bit more than what I can see on the Phenom. They have minimal padding but are comfortable for all day riding if you have some respectable chamy. The new ones are in low 200g with Ti rails if you are really concerned with weight.

The back of the Romins kick up so if you prefer a flatter profile saddle, I think the Toupe range is equivalent in all other aspects.

Avatar
JudgeDreddful | 9 years ago
0 likes

Pardon my ignorance as I'm new to this myself, but how do you measure your sit bones? Then once you have measured them (it?) how do you know whether your saddle is right for you?

Avatar
Simonsays50 replied to JudgeDreddful | 9 years ago
0 likes

get a piece of thick corrugated cardboard . put on a hard flat surface like a kitchen worktop. wearing only underwear sit on the cardboard leaning forward as you would on a saddle. rock slightly back/forward left /right. there will be 2 indentations corresponding to your sit bones. measure middle to middle. buy a saddle at least that width..preferably a little wider.
or go in to a specialized dealer and they will do it on a special bit of memory foam board.
most saddles are too narrow so your sit bones sit either side of the saddle and cause your pelvis to rock side to side as you pedal...disaster, loss of power and very uncomfortable.
saddles come in 135 145 and 155mm widths.. you probably need a 155, but get measured first.
simon

Avatar
massspike replied to JudgeDreddful | 9 years ago
0 likes
JudgeDreddful wrote:

Pardon my ignorance as I'm new to this myself, but how do you measure your sit bones? Then once you have measured them (it?) how do you know whether your saddle is right for you?

Specialized dealers will have their measuring device (a gel pad you sit on). It will likely give you a choice of sizes (e.g. for me it was 135 or 143). You then factor in your riding position (in my case more upright/relaxed = 143). That said, there are such limited choices for width (e.g. 135, 143, 155) you can probably guess yours. And since (at least around here) the only brand that offers you a choice that you can buy is Specialized it is a bit moot.

When I last changed my saddle, I rode to all the suitable retailers and swapped my saddle for one of their test saddles (if they don't offer this they are probably an unsuitable retailer). I then test rode it for an hour or until I hated it (whichever came first). Surprisingly it doesn't take long to figure out you hate a saddle (like every Fizik I tested). Because I would then return to my problematic saddle between stores (a 135mm lightweight non-Specialized that I bought on a whim) I really was able to figure out what worked for me.

Avatar
yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes

Thanks for your feedback. Quick update I have changed back to the original Avatar 143 but I'm finding it hard to accept I cannot get a better lighter saddle, the Romin is on my radar, ditto the Fizik Aliante.I need to look up how you measure your sit bone as I can see that helping me avoid buying more ill fitting saddles ATB Paul

Avatar
Simonsays50 | 9 years ago
0 likes

get/measure your sit bone width ...buy the correct width saddle. i am 200 lbs+ and have tried a bunch.. best by far is brooks titanium team pro. followed closely by specialized romin pro. go for the brooks..break it in and you'll never look back. better to be comfortable than save a few grams and have every long ride a pain.
simon

Avatar
Freddy56 | 9 years ago
0 likes

200lbs,
Worried about 100gms...jeeeze

Regardless If you were 100lbs- comfort if first

If your going specialized they are based on pelvic bone width. I'm 143, my son is 130mm and my father uses a155mm.

A specialized shop will fit ye

Avatar
massspike replied to Freddy56 | 9 years ago
0 likes
Freddy56 wrote:

Worried about 100gms...jeeeze

We'd appreciate it if you kept these heretical opinions private.

Signed,

The cycling equipment manufacturers.

Avatar
massspike | 9 years ago
0 likes

I used the Alias 143 which I believe is the predecessor to the Avatar. I switched to a Romin Evo 143 two seasons ago and am quite happy. Romin are a more contoured saddle vs the relatively flat Alias. It does have less padding (but is spec'd the same as the Phenom). If you go the Pro (carbon rail) route it is under 200g. I am only 185lbs but I don't think body weight is the right metric -- getting the right width is most critical part (imho).

P.S. the Phenom is actually marketed as an MTB saddle which could be messing up your road riding since the nose is more pronounced.

Avatar
backflipbedlem | 9 years ago
0 likes

why not just go back to the 143?
Comfort gotta be worth 100grams!  39

Avatar
CXR94Di2 | 9 years ago
0 likes

Adamo Road 2, I can't fault it for comfort. 100 mile rides are easy on this saddle. Forget lightweight if you're a 200 lb rider like me.

Avatar
yespsb replied to CXR94Di2 | 9 years ago
0 likes

Thanks, just Goggled one and they are err, mmhh  39 very strange looking things.

I'm not convinced they would work for my normal riding because the blurb states they are best for the static time trial mode seating whereas a lot of my riding is up and down twisty hills where I will move around quite a bit on the saddle.

Avatar
CXR94Di2 replied to yespsb | 9 years ago
0 likes

That's the common response, but I value the comfort over style. Function over form always. It takes a number of rides for your sit bones to adapt to the pressure points, then it's bliss. My adaption took half a dozen 20 - 30 mile outings.

If you value your tackle Adamo is a great saddle

Latest Comments