Castelli or Gore ?????????

by stumps   December 19, 2013  

There has been a couple of articles already about jackets - windproof and waterproof.

What i need some advice on is whether to go for a Castelli or Gore jacket. I'm getting some money for Christmas and my birthday so i'm going to splash out on a new jacket and cant decide which one to go for. I'll probably have about £160.00 to spend.

I already have an Altura waterproof so do i stick with that for rainy days although its not very packable and just get a windproof one ?

28 user comments

Oldest firstNewest firstBest rated

Can't comment on mens stuff but from a bird's perspective the castelli jackets are certainly among the best out there at the moment. Well tailored as well as being incredibly light. If I had a bit of cash to splash I'd go with one of them!

Check out Sportful while you're there as well by the way, they're the more "sensible" version of Castelli, same company & same factory, you might get more bang for your buck whilst not sacrificing style.

Merlin Cycles women's race team ~ http://www.merlincycles.com
Manx nerd peddler ~ http://mooleur.blogspot.com

mooleur's picture

posted by mooleur [542 posts]
19th December 2013 - 9:51

like this
Like (8)

Rapha Wind Jacket. It's really got to be thrown into the mix because it's within budget - £170, and is one of the best performing jackets I've come across.

Very lightweight, packs down very small, is wonderfully breathable and extremely comfortable - Can be used for three seasons. It's water resistant, and dries super quick too.

Either way, I would suggest getting windproof over waterproof - much more versatile.

@oddbydefault

oddbydefault's picture

posted by oddbydefault [93 posts]
19th December 2013 - 10:41

like this
Like (4)

Gore power active shell. Amazing jacket and well within budget

I'm so lazy I'd rather order something off Wiggle than go to the shops for Haribo...

posted by Mr Jono [98 posts]
19th December 2013 - 10:44

like this
Like (7)

Depends what you want and need from a jacket. If you've already got a waterproof jacket, then a good softshell jacket could be the best option. They're toasty warm, keep the wind out and are pretty good in light rain too, and really versatile - it's rarely cold enough that a softshell won't cope. You can easily stuff a few more layers underneath or over the top to adapt

My softshell jackets get a LOT more use than any other my hardshell or waterproof jackets. They're perfect for UK riding. With your budget you've got quite a large choice as well. Worth checking out available online discounts, can often get some good deals

David Arthur's picture

posted by David Arthur [1494 posts]
19th December 2013 - 11:35

like this
Like (7)

I have both a Castelli Elemento 7x and a Gore Xenon 2.0 SO Softshell in hi-viz that I use for commuting. Both are excellent. With your budget I'd go for the Gore just make sure you get the right size; it needs to be snug. Neither are totally waterproof (the Castelli hardly at all) but I've never really needed an additional waterproof with the Gore. It's quite similar to a Gabba in some respects. There's a few online shops that do the Gore at sub £150.

posted by AWP [71 posts]
19th December 2013 - 11:41

like this
Like (9)

Castelli every time.

The dhb one is very good though.

And I have one from CREW ROOM - which is actually a rowing brand. It's like a drysuit.

Sir Velo

Raleigh's picture

posted by Raleigh [1728 posts]
19th December 2013 - 12:47

like this
Like (7)

I've got the Gore Xenon 2.0 winstopper and it's brilliant. Has taken loads of abuse from about January this year and still going strong. Lots of ventilation options but warm when you need it, even when wet. The Castelli stuff is pretty though...

posted by Scowel [28 posts]
19th December 2013 - 14:09

like this
Like (7)

If you're looking for race fit then Castelli without a doubt. Gore make great kit but personally I'm less convinced by some of the tailoring.

I'd try on both and see though, like I say quality wise Gore is very good stuff.

Sportful are well worth a look if Castelli isn't quite your shape. Love the look of their kit and I don't doubt it's good but I just didn't fit into it as well.

posted by racingcondor [109 posts]
19th December 2013 - 21:01

like this
Like (8)

Not tried Castelli but have had a Gore windstopper for 3 years now and it's been great. Decent fit, rain resistant and with a long sleeved base layer is very effective in the windiest of weather.

posted by paulfg42 [374 posts]
19th December 2013 - 23:09

like this
Like (6)

Castelli all day, everyday. Nothing says 'commuter' and 'I heart Evans' like Gore.

posted by Colin Peyresourde [1120 posts]
19th December 2013 - 23:35

like this
Like (12)

i've got a Xenon 2.0 Windstopper Soft Shell Jacket and it is a fantastic bit of kit, wear it in autumn & spring just with a base layer underneath and in winter on rides when the temperature is below freezing I just add another layer underneath.

In my experience Gore stuff is better quality and better made than Castelli...

posted by edd23 [35 posts]
19th December 2013 - 23:42

like this
Like (8)

Castelli direct from china. Nothing ostracises you quite like rocking up to a club run wearing pretty much the same piece of kit as some mamil and letting them know it cost best part of a tenner.

I got a gore windstopper at a race one year, to be honest it has stayed tightly squashed into a water bottle most of the year, but when the weather really does turn south and it has to come out it stands up to the rain admirably.

Have to say though I find I cook to death wearing 'jackets' much prefer LS Roubaix(TM) type jerseys through winter

William Black's picture

posted by William Black [196 posts]
19th December 2013 - 23:50

like this
Like (7)

William Black wrote:
Castelli direct from china. Nothing ostracises you quite like rocking up to a club run wearing pretty much the same piece of kit as some mamil and letting them know it cost best part of a tenner.

Castelli, china..... mine says made in Croatia.

mrmo's picture

posted by mrmo [1075 posts]
20th December 2013 - 9:11

like this
Like (5)

Sportful Survival has got to be worth a mention in my opinion. Great Gore-Tex jacket, has kept me warm and dry in some atrocious weather recently. Within budget at the moment too.

posted by pirnie [184 posts]
20th December 2013 - 11:02

like this
Like (6)

Much of the Castelli stuff is made from Gore fabrics, so it's really down to the design and style of the jacket. Sportful own the Castelli brand.
Chinese Castelli? Well if it goes with the knock-off Cervelo, fake Oakleys and bargain Chanel No.5 you bought for the missus down the pub....

Make mine an Italian with Campagnolo on the side

posted by monty dog [363 posts]
20th December 2013 - 16:27

like this
Like (8)

mrmo wrote:
Castelli, china..... mine says made in Croatia.

Never said it was real Wink

William Black's picture

posted by William Black [196 posts]
20th December 2013 - 17:04

like this
Like (7)

Castelli, can't beat the Gabba kit!

glynr36's picture

posted by glynr36 [370 posts]
21st December 2013 - 1:06

like this
Like (4)

I think you won't go far wrong with Castelli. I have worn Assos, Rapha, Gore, Sportful, Santini and Endura. Castelli's tailoring is fantastic for riding/race position whilst I would say Gore is a bit flappy in the wind but great for standing about in.

Assos is OK but I have always had a problem with the seams, cut and price point - Swiss badged - Bulgarian made!

Endura is OK although not the best quality materials. Santini is like an italian version of Endura!

Castelli actually use Goretex in part of their construction for windproof jackets.
And their Nanoflex technology is great!

Be wary of Castellis sizing and go one up from what you normally size to e.g.: Large > Extra Large

Wait for the Jan sales and you will get a great bargain and maximise your budget!

posted by Clearboy [5 posts]
22nd December 2013 - 18:17

like this
Like (7)

Thanks everyone for the advice. After a great deal of thinking i'm going to go for the Castelli Gabba long sleeved and hope i can get it in one of the sales a bit cheaper.

If you must break the law, do it to seize power: in all other cases observe it. Gaius Julius Caesar.

stumps's picture

posted by stumps [2714 posts]
23rd December 2013 - 10:27

like this
Like (3)

Anyone know how the Gabba sizes up in the arms? Last time I tried one on, the shop only had a short sleeved medium, and a long sleeved large. The arms in the large long sleeve were about right, but the body in the medium was much better - nice and tight. I'm a 70kg 6'1" lanky person.

posted by bashthebox [640 posts]
23rd December 2013 - 20:06

like this
Like (5)

I'm about the same height (slightly heavier) and the arms on a medium ls gabba are fine for me.

posted by MattT53 [126 posts]
23rd December 2013 - 21:18

like this
Like (4)

I've enjoyed my Gabba in the few weeks I've had it, with a merino baselayer it's been warm enough down to around 0C.

On fit I find a medium fine, but I'm c 5'10" and 10.5st

I quite fancy an espresso due as well, but I can't really justify it

posted by Stratman [36 posts]
23rd December 2013 - 21:39

like this
Like (5)

Stratman wrote:
I've enjoyed my Gabba in the few weeks I've had it, with a merino baselayer it's been warm enough down to around 0C.

On fit I find a medium fine, but I'm c 5'10" and 10.5st

I quite fancy an espresso due as well, but I can't really justify it

When it comes to cycling gear you can always justify it...... Smile

If you must break the law, do it to seize power: in all other cases observe it. Gaius Julius Caesar.

stumps's picture

posted by stumps [2714 posts]
24th December 2013 - 13:41

like this
Like (0)

Stumps, I've been using a Gore Xenon SO since '11 and have just bought a Castelli Gabba (LS) which I've used for about 10 training rides and commuting since the start of November. Just using Gabba with LS polyester Helly Henson base layer. The 2 jackets are made of the same windstopper material (I think) and are about the same price.

Some comparative observations-

Gabba-Slightly racier fit. Lighter. May just fit in a jersey pocket. Very bright in yellow. Above standard build quality. Can be cold to start with (unlined) then too hot despite vents under arms. Chilly round neck. Pro look if you get a black one!

Xenon-Very slightly looser fit on arms, still quite racy through body. Exceptional warmth with strategically placed micro fleece backing, and venting under arms and also at end of sleeves (unlike Gabba), making it more stable temperature wise. You're warmer when you start then don't overheat. Better detailing-insulated neck, zip garage, zippered rear pocket. Neck edge has just started to delaminate but v minor and not a problem in use.

I expect both jackets to be equally waterproof BUT my friends Gabba has lost its original repellency in 6 months. My Gore has had 2 winters constant use commuting and training everyday and I have never applied DWR yet its as water repellent as ever.

If I could only have one jacket the Gore would win easily, it's a miracle jacket and relatively my most usable piece of kit-quality up there or surpassing my Rapha Pro Team jacket/bib shorts & Assos bib shorts .

Hope this helps.

posted by nadsta [6 posts]
24th December 2013 - 15:45

like this
Like (4)

Bloody Gabba must be so popular - no one has it in any sales Sad

posted by bashthebox [640 posts]
26th December 2013 - 13:29

like this
Like (2)

bashthebox wrote:
Anyone know how the Gabba sizes up in the arms? Last time I tried one on, the shop only had a short sleeved medium, and a long sleeved large. The arms in the large long sleeve were about right, but the body in the medium was much better - nice and tight. I'm a 70kg 6'1" lanky person.

Personally I've gone with the short sleeved version and Nanoflex am warmers. Bit more versatile

posted by VeloPeo [219 posts]
27th December 2013 - 14:26

like this
Like (1)

Oh and Castelli Cafe have them on sale for £120 SS / £148 LS
http://www.castellicafe.co.uk/castelli-gabba-ws-mens-jersey

posted by VeloPeo [219 posts]
27th December 2013 - 17:38

like this
Like (2)

stumps wrote:
Stratman wrote:
I've enjoyed my Gabba in the few weeks I've had it, with a merino baselayer it's been warm enough down to around 0C.

On fit I find a medium fine, but I'm c 5'10" and 10.5st

I quite fancy an espresso due as well, but I can't really justify it

When it comes to cycling gear you can always justify it...... Smile

Stumps - I did in the end, I didn't hold out for long

posted by Stratman [36 posts]
28th December 2013 - 23:38

like this
Like (0)